WHERE LANGUAGE AND FUN MEET
  • Home
  • IB Language
    • IBDP Ab Initio Student Workbook
    • English
    • French
    • German
    • Japanese
    • Mandarin
    • Spanish
    • IBDP Ab Initio Portfolio
    • IBDP How to Ace English
    • IBDP How to Ace Mandarin
    • IBDP How to Ace Spanish
    • IBDP Language B Portfolio
    • IB MYP Portfolio
    • How to order our resources
    • Pricelist
    • Customer feedback
  • IBDP Language A SSST
    • SSST logistical support
    • SSST tutor support >
      • Our SSST tutors
    • SSST paper/oral grading
    • SSST diagnostic
    • SSST selected online lessons
    • SSST and Language Policy
    • SSST Coordinator training
    • SSST Languages
    • SSST Fees and conditions
    • Free ! PRL Authors and Texts
  • MIH Services
    • Student travel >
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • North Korea (DPRK)
    • IB Workshops / Training
    • Consultancies
    • Experiential travel
    • Author visits
    • Volunteaching
    • Publications >
      • More than a Game
      • A Journey through North Korea
  • Free stuff
    • Teaching resources >
      • IB teaching resources
      • Ab Initio >
        • Visual stimuli
    • Language and Literature match-ups
    • Videos >
      • IB Language videos
    • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Contact
Our blog keeps you up to date with the latest developments in the world of language, travel, volunteaching and educational publishing.  We also highlight the most current discussions taking place in our Facebook groups. 
Your contributions are welcomed !

Student placement in Language Ab Initio and Language B

8/25/2019

2 Comments

 
One of the most interesting, and often controversial, discussion in a Group 2 workshop is the one about student placement in the Language Ab Initio and Language B courses.
We've all taken part in these conversations and we've all made up our mind as to which students we allow to enrol in either course.  Or … has the decision been taken for us ?
In past years the IB provided some guidance by stating that the Language Ab Initio course is designed for students who have no or very minimal experience with/in the target language.  The Language B course, on the other hand, is supposedly destined for students who have relatively significant experience with/in the target language.
Vague boundaries that offer too many possible interpretations and applications.
What does it mean to have had 'minimal exposure' to the target language ? Many possible scenarios present themselves and deserve their own discussion and reflection :
- is a year of language study in one secondary school the same as a year of language study in another secondary school ?
- is there a number of class hours we should count, in case one secondary school offers three weekly hours of language acquisition whereas another secondary school only offers 40 minutes per week ?
- is there a particular curriculum that must have been followed for us to decide whether the student has had 'minimal' or 'significant' exposure to the target language ? Can we assume that every MYP school covers the same language acquisition curriculum in its last two MYP years ?
- to what extent does 'living in a target language culture" contribute to the student's minimal or significant exposure, and how do we measure it ?
- can we assume that a teenager who lives in a target language culture automatically picks up 'significant' amounts of language ? Over how many years ?
- if one of the parents speaks the target language but the family uses another lingua franca, is there an unfair advantage for the child when studying the same target language ?
- and what about the comment "I've studied <language x> for seven years but I haven't learned anything and I still can't say anything !" …
All of these questions, and many more, don't have a straight-forward answer.  Schools will be looking at their Language Ab Initio candidates and their Language B candidates on a case by case basis.  A combination of the answers to the above questions may be a good start in the decision-making process.

But … we are aware that there are other factors at work, factors that don't have much to do with previous learning, prior exposure, minimal knowledge, basic understanding, scattered schooling … factors that don't look back into the student's past but rather at the student's future …

Shall we list these factors and nod in agreement when we recognise one that's at work in the school down the road ?

- school pressure to achieve high grades
- parental pressure to achieve high grades
- student pressure to achieve high grades
- school's ability to publish and parade its excellent DP results
- keeping it simple and putting Language B and Language Ab Initio in one classroom
- keeping it cheap and putting Language B and Language Ab Initio in one classroom
- pressure on teachers to produce high grades (appraisal)
- 'well, everyone else does it ...'
- etc.

The IB guides tell us that the students in Group 2 should find an appropriate academic challenge in their Language B course or their Language Ab Initio course.  Surely a student who's had five years of prior study isn't going to get challenged in the Language Ab Initio course.  If that student claims not to have learned anything in those five years, it's probably a good time to start learning a different language.  

What's your take on this ? Any anecdotes or real-life situations to share ? And how does your school deal with the above pressure points ?

Click that 'Reply' button please ...


2 Comments
Des OSullivan
8/26/2019 11:30:37 am

Hi, I have a similar situation at present with students who are advanced in English, some have studied in Canada or England, and they want to do SL Language B in English.

Right now, I know they will achieve a 7 in HL, but it feels unfair to the students whose level of English is intermediate and are studying the language at SL.

I believe they should be studying the ab initio course, but as you say there are many external factors. What do you think I should do?

Reply
Ronny link
8/26/2019 04:06:28 pm

Hello Des, if I understand you correctly then you have advanced students and intermediate students in English. The advanced students belong in Language A (they may study two languages A if they are proficient in both), and the intermediate students belong in Language B. Neither of these groups belong in Language Ab Initio, which is a course for beginners. I hope this helps you forward. Best wishes.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    We are practising Language Ab Initio, B and A teachers, examiners and workshop leaders for the International Baccalaureate.  We author and publish the “Language Ab Initio Student Workbook”, the various Language Portfolios (for Ab Initio, B and MYP) and the How to Ace Language Ab Initio and Language B series.  We are also a language acquisition and mother tongue consultants and tireless advocates for mother tongue entitlement in international education.  Beyond our lives as linguists, we travel the world, we publish novels, we practice photography, we play and coach football coach, we write and we read.  

    Archives

    September 2019
    August 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    September 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • IB Language
    • IBDP Ab Initio Student Workbook
    • English
    • French
    • German
    • Japanese
    • Mandarin
    • Spanish
    • IBDP Ab Initio Portfolio
    • IBDP How to Ace English
    • IBDP How to Ace Mandarin
    • IBDP How to Ace Spanish
    • IBDP Language B Portfolio
    • IB MYP Portfolio
    • How to order our resources
    • Pricelist
    • Customer feedback
  • IBDP Language A SSST
    • SSST logistical support
    • SSST tutor support >
      • Our SSST tutors
    • SSST paper/oral grading
    • SSST diagnostic
    • SSST selected online lessons
    • SSST and Language Policy
    • SSST Coordinator training
    • SSST Languages
    • SSST Fees and conditions
    • Free ! PRL Authors and Texts
  • MIH Services
    • Student travel >
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • North Korea (DPRK)
    • IB Workshops / Training
    • Consultancies
    • Experiential travel
    • Author visits
    • Volunteaching
    • Publications >
      • More than a Game
      • A Journey through North Korea
  • Free stuff
    • Teaching resources >
      • IB teaching resources
      • Ab Initio >
        • Visual stimuli
    • Language and Literature match-ups
    • Videos >
      • IB Language videos
    • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Contact